Indecision Affecting Murder Trial - Local news, weather, sports Savannah | WSAV On Your Side

Indecision Affecting Murder Trial

Posted: Updated:
Savannah, Georgia -

Indecision by one defendant in a murder case is leading to a delay in trial for another -- and the possible loss of a plea deal for himself. As part of a plea deal in the case he accepted back in November, John Montrell Small was expected to testify against his brother on trial for the same murder. It was set to begin this week, but everything screeched to a halt when the Judge announced Small had changed his mind.

Judge Timothy Walmsley addressed John Small on Friday regarding a letter Small had written last month to the Public Defender raising two issues, "One is your representation in this case and the other is your desire to withdraw your guilty plea that is currently before the court." Defense Counsel Brian Daly sat quietly while Small spoke to the Judge about his concerns, "What specifically is your objection to your current counsel?", asked Judge Walmsley. "I mean it's like everything that I talk to him about - he doesn't seem to agree or it's always a different story about what's going on," said Small.

Small admitted he had no legal background or training so the Judge explained his options regarding his defense to murder charges in the shooting death of Timothy Randolph back in April of 2012. Judge Walmsley then took a recess to allow small and his attorney to talk...afterwards - a startling announcement from Daly, "Mr. Small has informed me he does not wish to have me withdraw from the case and he also wished not to withdraw his plea in the case." Which didn't sit well with Prosecutor Matthew Breedon, "He has violated the terms of his negotiated plea even if he now chooses not to withdraw his plea. By refusing to come in and testify in the trial of Devontay Small - forcing that case to be continued - stating that he wanted to withdraw his plea…I do not want to be in a situation now where we set down Devontay Small for trial and this happens either right before the trial or even worse - in the middle of the trial." Breedon said the State would either rescind the entire plea offer or put forth one other option.

That option will be discussed with Small over the weekend. If he does not plead - his trial will move forward in early March - with his brother's to follow.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Sheriff's Office showcases "Faces of Meth" program as a lesson to all

    Sheriff's Office showcases "Faces of Meth" program as a lesson to all

    Monday, July 21 2014 11:33 AM EDT2014-07-21 15:33:26 GMT
    Faces of Meth™ is a project of the Multnomah County Sheriff's Office in Oregon. This project began when a deputy in the Corrections Division Classification Unit, Deputy Bret King, put together mug shots of persons booked into the Multnomah County Detention Center. Deputy King worked with his co-workers in the Classification Unit to identify people who had been in custody more than once. He then worked to verify criminal records and files to determine and assure a history of methamphetamine re...
    Faces of Meth™ is a project of the Multnomah County Sheriff's Office in Oregon. This project began when a deputy in the Corrections Division Classification Unit, Deputy Bret King, put together mug shots of persons booked into the Multnomah County Detention Center. Deputy King worked with his co-workers in the Classification Unit to identify people who had been in custody more than once. He then worked to verify criminal records and files to determine and assure a history of methamphetamine re...
  • Mysterious "woman in black" spotted in Tennessee

    Mysterious "woman in black" spotted in Tennessee

    A mysterious figure is capturing the attention of social media. She's been nicknamed "the woman in black" and she's been spotted in different parts of east Tennessee including Madisonville, Athens, Sweetwater and now Morgan County.
    A mysterious figure is capturing the attention of social media. She's been nicknamed "the woman in black" and she's been spotted in different parts of east Tennessee including Madisonville, Athens, Sweetwater and now Morgan County.
  • Family & friends poisoned by fish caught on vacation

    Family & friends poisoned by fish caught on vacation

    Tuesday, July 22 2014 8:00 AM EDT2014-07-22 12:00:09 GMT
    Karen Goncalves gave her son, Austin, a dream vacation fishing in the Bahamas. The 15-year-old loves fishing and spends much of his spare time on the water. They went with a friend of his and Karen's boyfriend. But a few days into the vacation they all got violently ill.They were rushed to a hospital for treatment and placed on IV fluids, but the medical staff didn't immediately know what was wrong. They were all flow...
    Karen Goncalves gave her son, Austin, a dream vacation fishing in the Bahamas. The 15-year-old loves fishing and spends much of his spare time on the water. They went with a friend of his and Karen's boyfriend. But a few days into the vacation they all got violently ill.They were rushed to a hospital for treatment and placed on IV fluids, but the medical staff didn't immediately know what was wrong. They were all flow...
Powered by WorldNow

1430 East Victory Drive
Savannah, GA 31404

Telephone: 912.651.0300
Fax: 912.651.0320
Email: newsemailalert@wsav.com

Can't find something?
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Media General Communications Holdings, LLC. A Media General Company.